My recent test drive of the Brompton brought home to me the effect of, and the need for, a good perch. The streets of London are not, surprisingly, paved with gold and having a comfortable saddle, fit for purpose is an essential, often overlooked piece of kit.
The state of London’s roads make a good saddle essential. Those pot-holes and bumps in most of the so-called cycle lanes are a joke! Actually, not a joke…a bone-jarring reality for most of us.
Swayed towards a Brooks saddle
Until a couple of years ago I probably wouldn’t have thought twice about changing the saddle on any bike I bought. Indeed, I’ve ridden my old Trek hybrid with the saddle that came with it for about 18 years.
Only when I bought a commuter bike did I get round to changing the saddle. Mostly because I wanted to try a Brooks saddle and the bike shop persuaded me that it would be a good idea. The original bike had a Specialized BG Sonoma saddle which whilst not uncomfortable was not really in keeping with the style of the bike.
I bought it on the Bike-to-work scheme so the extra cost of putting mudguards on and a new saddle was partly borne by the company I work for.
I bought the Flyer S model and away I went. I had heard lots of horror stories about Brooks, the need to break them in and so forth, but I followed the instructions about proofing and I’ve never looked back. It took me about a week of daily riding to get comfortable and now I find the suspended leather saddle the only way to travel.
When I bought the Wilier, the saddle that came with it was a Selle Italia XR, which, for me, was like sitting on a razor blade. I paid for this one myself and the extra cost of a new saddle was, at the time, a little more than I could bear.
Rather rather than buy a Brooks or other leather saddle, I put the Specialized Sonoma from my commuter bike on there which seems to do the job.
The more padding the more pain
It’s only when I ride another saddle that I realise how uncomfortable the normal padded ones are, like the one on the Brompton. It seems that the more padding there is, the more jarring the ride. The Flyer S is the women’s shortened version of the standard model but I really didn’t notice the difference so when I bought the B17, I went for the men’s version, the Standard. On a more forward leaning position I think that I should have gone for the ‘S’.
Without what Bike Snob calls his ‘pants yabbies’ to support, the longer version does seem a little long for me but nevertheless it is much more comfortable than anything else. Suspended leather saddles just seem to absorb those bumps and lumps in the road in a way that extra padding just doesn’t.
Many more years ago than I care to remember, I did the London-Brighton bike ride on my Trek and I remember a stage where, rising out of the saddle on a hill almost made me sick with the pain. A combination perhaps of lack of miles in the saddle and a lack of fitness but, even with a gel cover it was hellish. I’ve since ridden that far in a day and felt no ill effects on a leather saddle.
I may be more used to it now but a few weeks back I had a big ride in Antwerp on the Trek and the feeling on my nether regions was the same. Pain. Maybe saddle technology has come a long way because I don’t get that pain from the Specialized on the Wilier but for daily riding, I find the leather saddle the only way to go.
Which saddle style do you find most comfortable?
Join 5,112 fellow cyclists who are subscribed to the London Cyclist newsletter
Sign up for our free newsletter to get...
- Advice on the best cycling gear
- A Friday roundup of all the latest London cycling news
- Exclusive content not available on the blog
Subscribe today, and get exclusive access forever! (It's free)
*No spam, ever!
As seen on The Guardian, BBC and The Independent.